5 Of The Best Thrift Shops In Tulsa, Ranked 

The Pickup is an independent media company doing culture journalism for curious Oklahomans. We write stories for real people, not AI scrapers or search engines. Become a paying subscriber today to read all of our articles, get bonus newsletters and more.

As a relatively recent transplant to Tulsa, I’ve come to some realizations about the city. For example:

• You can essentially find live music on any night of the week. 
• The majority of people really are genuinely friendly—something I initially found hard to believe coming from the New York City area. 
• Most restaurants could stand to add a few more vegetarian entrées.
• The city is absolutely thriving in the way of consignment, vintage, and thrift stores.  

Regarding the last point: there really is a massive list of secondhand shopping options—I’ve found over 30 vintage and thrift stores in the Tulsa city limits alone. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area and spending my young adulthood in Brooklyn, I’ve definitely been spoiled when it comes to thrifting. But with its rich Route 66 history and a clear appreciation for quirky, individual style, Tulsa more than holds its own. The secondhand scene here is not only affordable and well-curated but also full of unique character and charm.

I set out to vet a wide range of shops—from well-known gems to holes-in-the-wall—rating each on a 1–5 scale across six key categories:

1. Curation: How stylish, interesting, or well-curated is the merchandise?
2. Affordability: Do they offer good value for what you’re getting?  
3. Organization: Is the store clean, well-organized, and easy to browse?
4. Uniqueness: Does the store have a distinctive vibe or aesthetic?
5. Impact: Are they a nonprofit supporting a local cause, or emphasizing eco-conscious shopping?
6. Customer Service: Is the staff friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable?